Is Goat's milk right for your baby?

Before this moment, you probably never envisioned spending extensive hours researching various types of milk available in the market to find the ideal option for your baby. This research encompasses traditional cow's milk and plant-based alternatives like soy, almond, and pea milk, with goat's milk emerging as another choice derived from animals.

In reality, goat's milk or goat's milk-based formulas may present a wholesome and nutritious alternative for babies with sensitivities to cow's milk or those with health concerns related to cow's milk. On the flip side, it's essential to recognize that goat's milk products may not suit every situation.

If you're contemplating the switch to goat milk, we understand you want to make an informed decision. Since you're committed to ensuring your baby receives the best possible nutrition, we'll clarify when it might be a suitable choice and when it might be based on something other than expert opinions.

Expert Insights on the Safety of Goat's Milk

The choice of nutrition for your baby is influenced by various factors, including your personal health beliefs, your baby's health conditions (such as eczema, allergies, or cow's milk sensitivities), and the availability of resources. However, regardless of these factors, safety should always be the top priority.

Generally, goat's milk is considered a safe alternative to cow's milk, but following the recommended timeline for introducing it to your baby is crucial. Goat's milk-based formulas are safe from birth to 12 months, but fresh goat's milk, as well as other non-formula pure kinds of milk that aren't breast milk, should be completely avoided during the first 12 months of your baby's life, as advised by the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP).

This caution arises because goat's milk alone doesn't provide adequate infant nutrition and can lead to severe health and developmental issues if used as a substitute for infant formula or breast milk. Additionally, infants' digestive systems are not sufficiently developed to handle the high protein content in animal-derived kinds of milk.

However, once your baby reaches the age of 1, it's safe to introduce pasteurized pure goat's milk. (Raw, unpasteurized goat milk can contain harmful bacteria that pose serious risks to infants and young children.)

Common Reasons for Considering Goat's Milk

One of the primary motivations for parents considering goat's milk is the presence of a cow's milk allergy or intolerance, which affects up to 3 percent of infants in developed countries. While goat's milk may seem like a viable option for babies with cow's milk allergies, it's essential to note that it may only be safe for babies with perceived intolerances to cow's milk formula.

Symptoms of a cow's milk allergy range from mild issues like diarrhea and coughing to severe and potentially life-threatening symptoms such as shortness of breath and anaphylaxis.

It's worth distinguishing between a cow's milk allergy and cow's milk protein intolerance, which affects up to 5 percent of infants in their first 1 to 3 months of life. Goat's milk is higher in protein and has properties that make it easier to digest, but it contains lactose in smaller amounts. Therefore, goat's milk is not a suitable replacement for babies with cow milk allergies or cow milk protein intolerance.

If you are considering replacing cow's milk formulas or cow's milk with goat's milk products, it's essential to consult and be supervised by your child's pediatrician, especially if there's an allergy involved.

Nutritional Comparison Between Goat's Milk and Cow's Milk

From a nutritional standpoint, pure goat's milk typically contains slightly more protein and fat than cow's milk. Goat's milk also tends to be richer in calcium, potassium, vitamin A, and copper, among other essential vitamins and minerals. However, it's important to note that goat's milk is lower in some vitamins compared to cow's milk.

For instance, cow's milk contains higher vitamin B12 and folate levels, while goat's milk boasts more potassium and vitamin A. Overall, in terms of nutritional content, cow's milk and goat's milk are quite similar.

Another notable nutritional difference is in lactose, the natural sugar found in all animal milks. Many people have difficulty digesting lactose, resulting in digestive problems. Goat's milk contains less lactose, which is why individuals with cow milk sensitivities may tolerate goat milk better.

Goat's Milk-Based Formulas

Some new mothers are unable or choose not to breastfeed, and in such cases, they may consider goat's milk-based formulas as an alternative. A study from 2014 demonstrated that infants fed goat's milk formulas experienced healthy development comparable to those fed cow's milk formulas.

However, it's crucial to note that the nutritional content of goat's milk-based formulas can vary by brand. Therefore, discussing your formula choice with your pediatrician is advisable to ensure it meets the necessary nutritional and safety standards. Your pediatrician may recommend vitamin D supplementation if the formula lacks it, and iron supplementation may also be considered.

Goat's Milk for Eczema and Reflux

While researching goat's milk, you may come across anecdotal claims suggesting it can alleviate the severity of eczema or reflux in infants. However, substantial scientific research supporting these direct benefits is currently lacking. If you have concerns that milk products are related to your child's eczema or reflux, it's best to consult with their pediatrician for expert advice and guidance before making any dietary changes.

Drawbacks of Goat's Milk

Goat's milk is an animal product and shares allergenic properties with cow's milk. Therefore, if your child has a genuine allergy to cow's milk, there's a high likelihood they'll also be allergic to goat's milk, although the severity may vary. Research has indicated that goat's milk can trigger reactions in more than 90 percent of children with cow's milk allergies.

As mentioned earlier, it's crucial to consult your child's doctor before considering goat's milk or any alternative milk product. Additionally, accessibility and cost can pose challenges when incorporating goat's milk into your child's diet. Goat's milk is less commonly found on typical grocery store shelves, so you may need to seek it out at health food stores, special order it, or purchase it online.

Lastly, if you've ever tasted goat cheese, you're aware of its distinctive earthy flavor, which differs from cheese made from cow's milk. A similar taste profile can be expected with goat's milk, and some young children may initially reject it, particularly if they're accustomed to cow's milk products.

If you need help determining where to begin, consult your child's pediatrician for recommendations on specific brands or provide them with the nutritional information of several options you've found to determine what's best for your baby.

Safest Types of Goat's Milk

For babies under 12 months, it's advisable to consider nutritionally appropriate formulas. Goat's milk-based infant formulas should be fortified with essential vitamins and minerals. Reviewing the nutritional label with your baby's pediatrician is crucial to ensure it meets all the requirements. Your pediatrician may recommend vitamin D or iron supplementation if needed.

For toddlers and children aged 1 and older who consume pure goat's milk, the standards are somewhat relaxed because they should receive nutrition from various foods. Although nutritional content may vary slightly among different brands, it's imperative to ensure that your goat's milk is pasteurized.

If you're interested in exploring our goat milk, click here: Kendamil Goat Milk. 

If you'd like to give goat milk a try, you can grab a sample of our delicious goat milk right here: Kendamil Samples.